FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $200+

SHOP 2024 GIFT GUIDE

SHOP NOW, PAY LATER WITH SHOP PAY AT CHECKOUT

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Check out our new arrivals

New Arrivals

Gifts Under $25

522 Results

Clear filters
Thankful Thanksgiving - Board Book
new

Thankful Thanksgiving - Board Book

Cottage Door Press

$8.99

Farm Babies - "Toughy" Book
new

Farm Babies - "Toughy" Book

Cottage Door Press

$8.99

Unicorns Love Colors - "Toughy" Book
new

Unicorns Love Colors - "Toughy" Book

Cottage Door Press

$8.99

Dinosaurs Big and Little - "Toughy" Book
new

Dinosaurs Big and Little - "Toughy" Book

Cottage Door Press

$8.99

You're Here for a Reason

You're Here for a Reason

Macmillan

$8.99

Wherever You Are

Wherever You Are

Macmillan

$8.99

If Animals Tried to Be Kind

If Animals Tried to Be Kind

Macmillan

$8.99

Crown on Your Head

Crown on Your Head

Macmillan

$8.99

Will You Be My Valentine?

Will You Be My Valentine?

Cottage Door Press

$8.99

Christmas Cheer

Christmas Cheer

Hachette Book Group

$8.99

Babydoll Diapers - 3 Pack

Babydoll Diapers - 3 Pack

Adora

$8.00

Caterpillar Wind-up Toy

Caterpillar Wind-up Toy

Two's Company

$8.00

6 colors
  • +2 more
Potty

Potty

Maileg

$8.00

2 colors
  • Off White
  • Rose
Beach Tube

Beach Tube

Maileg

$8.00

2 colors
Jewelry Polishing Cloth (PC-Pink SM)

Jewelry Polishing Cloth (PC-Pink SM)

Cherished Moments

$8.00

What Are Little Girls Made Of - Greeting Card Book
new

What Are Little Girls Made Of - Greeting Card Book

Cottage Door Press

$7.99

What Are Little Boys Made Of - Greeting Card Book
new

What Are Little Boys Made Of - Greeting Card Book

Cottage Door Press

$7.99

Little Green Frog Lift-a-Flap - Board Book
new

Little Green Frog Lift-a-Flap - Board Book

Cottage Door Press

$7.99

Halloween Lift-a-Flap - Board Book
new

Halloween Lift-a-Flap - Board Book

Cottage Door Press

$7.99

Little Blue Boat Lift-a-Flap - Board Book
new

Little Blue Boat Lift-a-Flap - Board Book

Cottage Door Press

$7.99

I'd Know You Anywhere, My Love

I'd Know You Anywhere, My Love

Macmillan

$7.99

Numbers Board Book

Numbers Board Book

Sourcebooks

$7.99

Tricycle Basket, Mouse

Tricycle Basket, Mouse

Maileg

$7.00

Christmas Collapsing Toy

Christmas Collapsing Toy

Mud Pie

$7.00

4 styles
  • Tree
  • Snowman
  • Santa
  • Elf
BFF Butterfly Share & Tear Necklaces

BFF Butterfly Share & Tear Necklaces

Great Pretenders

$7.00

Silly Lullaby

Silly Lullaby

Simon & Schuster

$6.99

Rug, flowers - Medium
new

Rug, flowers - Medium

Maileg

$6.00

Metal Box with Sliding Lid

Metal Box with Sliding Lid

Maileg

$6.00

1 color
Baby's "1st Curl" Bag

Baby's "1st Curl" Bag

Edward P. Boutross, Inc.

$6.00

2 colors
  • Blue
  • Pink
Dino-Mite Bath Buddies

Dino-Mite Bath Buddies

Two's Company

$6.00

5 colors
  • +1 more
Motor Skills Caterpillar

Motor Skills Caterpillar

Hauck

$6.00

2 colors
  • Pink
  • Blue
Miniature Striped Rug

Miniature Striped Rug

Maileg

$6.00

Mommy Hugs

Mommy Hugs

Hachette Book Group

$5.99

Furry Chick - FINAL SALE
Sale

Furry Chick - FINAL SALE

Sourcebooks

$7.99 $5.19 35% off

Gingerbread House, Paper Bag

Gingerbread House, Paper Bag

Maileg

$5.00

Jesus Loves Me - Board Book
new

Jesus Loves Me - Board Book

Cottage Door Press

$4.99

PARA’KITO® Roll-On - FINAL SALE
Sale

PARA’KITO® Roll-On - FINAL SALE

Para'Kito

$19.50 $4.88 75% off

Grandma Foldout Announcement - FINAL SALE
Sale

Grandma Foldout Announcement - FINAL SALE

Mud Pie

$17.00 $4.25 75% off

Rug, flowers - Small
new

Rug, flowers - Small

Maileg

$4.00

Back to School Football Wand - FINAL SALE
Sale

Back to School Football Wand - FINAL SALE

Over The Moon

$13.00 $3.25 75% off

6 colors
  • Preschool
  • 3K
  • 4K
  • Kindergarten
  • +2 more