FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $200+

SHOP 2024 GIFT GUIDE

SHOP NOW, PAY LATER WITH SHOP PAY AT CHECKOUT

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Check out our new arrivals

New Arrivals

Christmas Gifts

71 Results

Clear filters
Merry Mouse

Merry Mouse

Jellycat

$27.00

5 styles
  • Santa
  • Wreath
  • Bedtime
  • Present
  • +1 more
Merry Christmas Eyeglasses

Merry Christmas Eyeglasses

Demdaco

$9.00

6 styles
  • Wreath
  • Santa
  • Elf
  • Christmas Tree
  • +2 more
Christmas Collapsing Toy

Christmas Collapsing Toy

Mud Pie

$7.00

4 styles
  • Tree
  • Snowman
  • Santa
  • Elf
A Reindeer's Dream Book

A Reindeer's Dream Book

Jellycat

$15.00

Ball Ornaments

Ball Ornaments

Tiny Town Inc

$27.00

Christmas Bath Toys

Christmas Bath Toys

Mud Pie

$19.00

If I Were An Elf

If I Were An Elf

Jellycat

$13.00

Knit Reindeer Doll with Dress

Knit Reindeer Doll with Dress

Petit Ami

$40.00

Winter Warmer Otto Sausage Dog
new

Winter Warmer Otto Sausage Dog

Jellycat

$39.00

The Elf on the Shelf

The Elf on the Shelf

Tonies

$19.99

Christmas Nail Polish Set

Christmas Nail Polish Set

Mud Pie

$18.00

2 styles
  • Santa
  • Reindeer
Christmas Art Folio

Christmas Art Folio

Mud Pie

$21.00

2 styles
  • Santa
  • Reindeer
Bear-y Christmas by Shuler Studio

Bear-y Christmas by Shuler Studio

Bauble Stockings

$85.00

2 colors
  • Blue
  • Pink
The Nutcracker

The Nutcracker

Tonies

$19.99

Christmas Crayon Holder

Christmas Crayon Holder

Mud Pie

$12.00

2 styles
  • Santa
  • Tree
Christmas Sequin Tutu

Christmas Sequin Tutu

Mud Pie

$39.00

2 colors
Otto's Snowy Christmas Book

Otto's Snowy Christmas Book

Jellycat

$15.00

Sugar Plum Fairy Mouse - Medium

Sugar Plum Fairy Mouse - Medium

Jellycat

$29.00

Make Your Own Christmas Tree Kit

Make Your Own Christmas Tree Kit

Two's Company

$9.00

Paint Your Own Nativity

Paint Your Own Nativity

Mud Pie

$25.00

Ruby Jolly Gingerbread

Ruby Jolly Gingerbread

Jellycat

$31.00

A Christmas Carol and Tales

A Christmas Carol and Tales

Tonies

$14.99

Amuseable Hot Chocolate

Amuseable Hot Chocolate

Jellycat

$28.00

Christmas Colored Pencil Set

Christmas Colored Pencil Set

Mud Pie

$9.00

3 styles
  • Snowman
My First Christmas Tree Set

My First Christmas Tree Set

Mud Pie

$37.00

Leffy's Christmas Gift Book

Leffy's Christmas Gift Book

Jellycat

$14.00

Cosy Christmas Set, Mouse

Cosy Christmas Set, Mouse

Maileg

$32.00

Sofia Reindeer

Sofia Reindeer

Jellycat

$56.00

The Naughty Penguins Book

The Naughty Penguins Book

Jellycat

$15.00

Knit Reindeer Doll with Romper

Knit Reindeer Doll with Romper

Petit Ami

$39.00

Vintage Santa Milk & Cookies Set

Vintage Santa Milk & Cookies Set

Mud Pie

$29.00

Christmas Tales

Christmas Tales

Tonies

$14.99

Amusable Blue Spruce Christmas Tree

Amusable Blue Spruce Christmas Tree

Jellycat

$25.00

Crimson Santa

Crimson Santa

Jellycat

$27.00

Amuseable Christmas Tree

Amuseable Christmas Tree

Jellycat

from $22.00

2 colors
  • Small
  • Really Big
Santa's Favorite Chenille Plush Pillow
new

Santa's Favorite Chenille Plush Pillow

Iscream

$26.00

Santa Claus is Coming to Town Bath Balm
new

Santa Claus is Coming to Town Bath Balm

Musee

$15.00

Pink Village Boxed Balm
new

Pink Village Boxed Balm

Musee

$17.00

Pop-Up Surprise Winter in the Forest - Board Book
new

Pop-Up Surprise Winter in the Forest - Board Book

Cottage Door Press

$12.99

Christmas Mouse, Baby in Suitcase
new

Christmas Mouse, Baby in Suitcase

Maileg

$24.00